Will Americans Overspend for a Good Black Friday Deal? Apparently, Yes

A Dime Saved
4 min readNov 20, 2023
Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Black Friday is considered the biggest shopping day of the year, with many retailers slashing prices and hosting sale events.

With all the hype surrounding Black Friday, the question is: Will Americans ditch their budgets and overspend on deals this Black Friday?

Will they spend enough to bring big retailers into the black?

The answer, apparently, is yes.

Americans Will Overspend for a Good Deal

The majority, nearly 60 percent, say they are willing to go beyond their budget and overspend if they find a good deal.

The survey, which was conducted between 16 and 18 November this year, aims to explore online shoppers’ current attitudes toward Black Friday at a time of high inflation and looming recession.

They asked 1,716 adults what their planned budget is, whether they are willing to spend more if they find a good deal, and what method they would use to pay for their online purchases.

The full survey, including the methodology and infographics, can be found below.

Good Deal

The survey finds most online shoppers willing to spend more than they planned on black friday if they find a good deal.

Shoppers worldwide are looking forward to the end of this week when heavy discounts on clothes, electronics, toys, and other goods are set to make Christmas shopping a little more affordable. Due to the high inflation, however, prices may not seem as attractive as last year.

Still, millions take part in the Black Friday frenzy, and most shoppers are willing to spend more than they had planned if they find good deals.

According to a survey conducted by BonusInsider, around 60 percent of online shoppers are willing to overspend should they get a good discount.

Nearly 60% Willing To Spend More Than They Planned

Despite countless warnings against overspending by experts both on TV and online, most shoppers are willing to disregard basic financial discipline when it comes to Black Friday shopping.

The survey results show that 59.91% admit they would spend more than planned if they found good deals.

Only 5% Of Black Friday Shoppers Planning To Spend More Than $1,000

When asked about their budget for Black Friday shopping, most people said they are planning to spend between $200 and $1,000 — roughly 39% have a budget of $200 to $500, and 34% will spend $500 to $1,000. Approximately 13% of online shoppers are planning to spend between $100 and $200.

Those who will make low-cost purchases of up to $100 make up 8.9% of all respondents, while only 87 shoppers, or roughly 5.1%, are planning to spend more than $1,000 on Black Friday this year.

Credit and Debit Cards Preferred by Majority of Shoppers

Despite the wide variety of modern methods for paying online, traditional credit and debit cards such as Mastercard and Visa are still preferred by many when shopping on the Internet.

The most preferred method is the credit card, picked by 543 respondents (31.64%) in the survey, followed by e-wallets and mobile wallets like PayPal, Cash App or Venmo, picked by 507 shoppers (29.55%).

Another 344 respondents (20.05%) say they will use a debit card on Black Friday, while only 115 people (6.70%) choose to pay via bank transfer. An alternative to credit cards, the so-called BNPL (buy now, pay later) services are gaining popularity, although they’ve been around for just a few years.

A total of 109 shoppers (6.35%) picked BNPL as their preferred payment method for Black Friday as they can pay for their order at a later date or spread payments over time, often interest-free. Others choose cash on delivery (3.7%) and various prepaid methods (2.04%), such as gift cards, prepaid vouchers, and digital cards.

Discounts More Important to Black Friday Shoppers Than Brands

This year’s inflation, reaching a 41-year high this past June in the US and exceeding 10% across most of Europe, has made shoppers more cautious of prices.

Nearly 43% of respondents, 735 people, admit they will be shopping for the best deals on Black Friday, while only 639 say they will buy their preferred brands and products, regardless of the cost. 342 shoppers, roughly 20%, say the free shipping and return policies will matter more to them than the actual discounts they will get.

Read More:

6 Ways To Win Black Friday This Year

The Best Black Friday Tips That Will Help You Save Some Money